Mining Focus Africa

Top Menu

  • Subscribe
  • Minerals
  • Projects
  • Machinery
  • Video’s
  • Advertise
  • Magazine
  • Directory

Main Menu

  • Home
  • International News
  • Local News
  • Events
  • Business
  • Energy
  • Technology
  • Contact Us
Sign in / Join

Login

Welcome! Login in to your account
Lost your password?

Lost Password

Back to login
  • Subscribe
  • Minerals
  • Projects
  • Machinery
  • Video’s
  • Advertise
  • Magazine
  • Directory

logo

Header Banner

Mining Focus Africa

  • Home
  • International News
  • Local News
  • Events
  • Business
  • Energy
  • Technology
  • Contact Us
  • SRK’s decade in DRC evolves to local ownership

  • BIA Group to supply Furukawa & RTDrill brands across Central and West Africa for Euroforgroup

  • Mozambique the next frontier in graphite production

  • BASE Resources passes important resource milestones in Kenya

  • Cable, components and critical space exploration

  • Africa’s edge in the green mineral economy

  • Keeping the faith in EA public participation processes during Covid-19

  • Ivanplats seeks $420m financing to develop South Africa’s Platreef mine

  • Transforming the Logistics Operations of the African Mining Industry

  • Mining Indaba insights: Mines push on as South Africa plays catch-up

Projects
Home›Projects›Court stops construction of Kenya’s coal power plant. Here’s why

Court stops construction of Kenya’s coal power plant. Here’s why

By Micheal van Wyk
July 1, 2019
88
0
Share:

Kenyan judges have stopped plans to construct the country’s first ever coal-powered plant near the coastal town of Lamu, a Unesco World Heritage Site. The tribunal ruled that the National Environment Management Authority had failed to do a thorough environmental assessment. The Conversation Africa’s Moina Spooner asked David Obura, adjunct fellow, The University of Queensland to give some insights.

Why did the Kenyan government opt for a coal-powered fire station given the global move away from coal?

The government’s justification for the coal plant came from its “Vision 2030” goals for development, launched in 2008. Under this strategy, adequate, reliable, clean and affordable energy was highlighted as key to meeting the country’s growing demands.

The government anticipated that over the 20 years of the plan demand for energy would increase six-fold from about 1 800 MW to 15 000 MW peak load in 2030. About a quarter (26%) of the final installed capacity was expected to be obtained from geothermal, 19% from nuclear, and 13% from coal. Coal was seen as a cheaper substitute for more expensive oil, and to provide consistent baseload power.

However, cleaner fossil and non-fossil fuels are fast gaining advantage because of their improving cost to the user, measures of energy efficiency, reliability, stability of supply and low environmental impacts. And energy demand hasn’t risen as expected, remaining below 2000 MW.

Given all the above, it’s believed that vested interests are likely to be playing a role in Kenya’s push for the coal plant. The plant is owned by Amu Coal – a consortium of Kenyan and Chinese energy and investment firms. There are reports that China has positioned itself to help drive Kenya’s energy market while, in its shift to cleaner domestic energy, the country is moving its existing stock and labour abroad.

What are the particular environmental challenges that a plant like this presents?

The burning of coal will cause massive pollution to the air, fresh water and ocean.

Contributing to this is the fact that the coal intended for use, from South Africa and Kitui in Kenya, is bituminous – this means that it burns poorly and has particularly high levels of pollutants. South Africa has one of the highest emissions from coal power plants in the world, with widely documented effects on people and nature.

The plant will also dramatically increase Kenya’s national contribution to global carbon dioxide emissions.

On top of air pollution, coal leaves behind residue ash when it’s burned. The Lamu Coal Plant proposes a yard that will hold about 26 million cubic metres of ash and stand 26 metres high, in places less than three metres above sea level. This may remain as a permanent mound of waste – until eroded by the rising sea. This is a huge concern on the low-lying coastline – until recently sea level was projected to rise almost one metre by 2100, but new evidence including recent ice melt in Greenland, suggests this rate could be much higher.

The judges ruled that the environmental impact assessment was bad. How are they carried out in Kenya. Who is responsible for them?

Environmental Impact Assessments in Kenya are implemented by independent experts accredited through the Environmental Institute of Kenya. They are commissioned by project developers to carry out assessments.

The National Environment Management Authority is responsible for reviewing assessments for their content and quality. It has the power to approve or deny an environmental license for operations.

A portion of responsibility therefore lies with all three – environment management authority, the experts who are paid to carry out the studies and the project developers who commission and pay for them. But ultimately the buck stops with the national authority.

What went wrong?

The court case highlighted that the environmental challenges listed above were not adequately covered by the Environmental Impact Assessment. These include:

  • Detailed insights into how much pollution from coal, dust and ash the plant would produce, and how this would affect people, plants, animals and marine life;
  • How much and in what directions pollution would be spread by wind and water currents;
  • The impact of a changing climate, like rising sea levels, on the plant and the coal residue that it will leave behind;
  • sufficient and credible mitigation actions for all these impacts.

The court’s decision shines a light on these deficiencies and calls into question the fundamental role played by the environmental authority. It’s job is to review and maintain quality control over assessments. It clearly didn’t do that in this case. This mirrors an earlier case in which a High Court decision stopped dredging for the new Lamu port, adjacent to the coal plant.

For now, the court order has given the project proponents a clear directive to do a new environmental impact assessment if they want to go ahead with the plant. It could take a year or two to complete for a project of this scale. Many Lamu residents and environmental groups hope that the project will be shelved. Even if that doesn’t happen, at least a signal has been sent that future Environmental Impact Assessments must meet necessary standards, and will face critical scrutiny to ensure they do.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

Previous Article

Seychelles floating solar energy project moves into ...

Next Article

World’s largest single-site solar project begins commercial ...

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0

Micheal van Wyk

Related articles More from author

  • MineralsProjects

    Zambia Eyes Bigger Role in Running Copper Mines

    January 8, 2021
    By Micheal van Wyk
  • ProjectsTechnology

    China to accelerate work on iron ore projects in Australia and Africa

    January 5, 2021
    By Micheal van Wyk
  • Projects

    EXCLUSIVE: CANADA’S FIRST QUANTUM WEIGHS $1 BILLION ZAMBIAN COPPER MINE EXPANSION – DOCUMENT

    January 4, 2020
    By Micheal van Wyk
  • BusinessProjects

    juwi South Africa to build solar PV plant at Pan African’s Evander Mines

    December 16, 2020
    By Micheal van Wyk
  • Projects

    Rio completes initial work at Zambia copper project

    December 3, 2020
    By Micheal van Wyk
  • Projects

    Zambia threatens to liquidate Vedanta’s Konkola Copper Mines

    May 12, 2019
    By Micheal van Wyk

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You may be interested in

  • Minerals

    Kenya Targets $4.5 billion in Investment to Commercialize Crude

  • International News

    Mining and agriculture: Could repurposed farmland help create jobs?

  • International News

    Kenya: Nanok Urges State to Disclose Details of Mining Activities in Turkana

Watch

  • EnergyVideo's

    South Africa reveals recovery plan for mining and energy sector

    Government has tabled a recovery plan to restore business confidence, stimulate investments, safeguard and create jobs in the mining and energy sector. “The Mining and Energy Recovery Plan intends to ...
  • Video's

    The draft petroleum Bill, skills development and how SA can benefit from Mozambique’s LNG project

    Adrian Strydom, acting CEO at South African Oil and Gas Association chats to African Oil Week on the draft Upstream Petroleum Resource Development Bill, Integrated Resource Plan, skill development for ...
  • Video's

    Steel production likely to stagnate or decline this year, says Roskill

    https://cisp.cachefly.net/assets/articles/attachments/82191_2020-05-05_roskill.mp4
  • Video's

    South Africa’s economy dire in comparison to rest of Africa

      Dr Azar Jammine, Director and Chief Economist at Econometrix, highlights the economic disparity between South Africa, West Africa and East Africa and how this could be an opportunity for ...
  • EventsVideo's

    Good Chemistry at Mining Indaba

    Under the umbrella of the new AECI Mining pillar, AECI Mining Explosives (AEL Intelligent Blasting) and AECI Mining Chemicals (Senmin), will offer solutions that focus on the customer and their ...

Timeline

  • February 24, 2021

    SRK’s decade in DRC evolves to local ownership

  • February 24, 2021

    BIA Group to supply Furukawa & RTDrill brands across Central and West Africa for Euroforgroup

  • February 23, 2021

    Mozambique the next frontier in graphite production

  • February 22, 2021

    BASE Resources passes important resource milestones in Kenya

  • February 19, 2021

    Cable, components and critical space exploration

Find us on Facebook

About Us

Mining Focus Africa provides valuable information on minerals’, events, exploration, energy and mining developments throughout Africa. It reports on the continent’s renaissance in mining and market opportunities associated with it.

Published 4 times a year, Mining Focus Africa is also available as a value-adding Digital online platform including weekly newsletter, online subscription and quarterly E-magazine downloads.

  • Recent

  • Popular

  • Comments

  • SRK’s decade in DRC evolves to local ownership

    By Micheal van Wyk
    February 24, 2021
  • BIA Group to supply Furukawa & RTDrill brands across Central and West Africa for Euroforgroup

    By Micheal van Wyk
    February 24, 2021
  • Mozambique the next frontier in graphite production

    By Micheal van Wyk
    February 23, 2021
  • BASE Resources passes important resource milestones in Kenya

    By Micheal van Wyk
    February 22, 2021
  • The way that minerals are mined affects conflict in eastern Congo

    By Micheal van Wyk
    July 30, 2019
  • Miners welcome stance against ‘blatant corruption’ in South Africa

    By Micheal van Wyk
    August 31, 2020
  • Wafi-Golpu a ‘game-changer’ for growing South Africa miner

    By Micheal van Wyk
    December 7, 2020
  • East Africa mining boom spells doom for environment

    By Micheal van Wyk
    December 4, 2020
  • JAQLEE CONSTRUCTION COMMENCING
    on
    February 1, 2021

    Mota-Engil picks up mining contract at Vedanta’s Gamsberg mine

    Good Day. Would like ...
  • www.xmc.pl
    on
    January 31, 2021

    Shock resignation of AngloGold Ashanti CEO after less than two years

    Spot on with this ...
  • Edison Forbes
    on
    January 6, 2021

    Contact Us

    I think this is ...
  • หนังโป๊
    on
    January 4, 2021

    Miners welcome stance against ‘blatant corruption’ in South Africa

    Excellent article. I certainly ...

Contact Us

Head Office
5 The Ferns, 364 Pretoria Avenue, Randburg, South Africa, 2194

Tell : +27 67 212 7565
Fax: 086 678 6956
www.lothbrokmedia.com

Accounts
Info@lothbrokmedia.com

Zambia
33 Malata Road, Madras,Lusaka, Zambia 3928Tell:+ 26 76 136 3654
Email Info
Info@miningfocusafrica.com

 

  • Contact
  • Adverts
© Copyright www.miningfocusafrica.com. All rights reserved.
Please wait...

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to be notified when our article is published? Enter your email address and name below to be the first to know.
SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTER NOW