Mining Focus Africa

Top Menu

  • Subscribe
  • Minerals
  • Projects
  • Machinery
  • Video’s
  • Advertise
  • Magazine
  • Directory

Main Menu

  • Home
  • International News
  • Local News
  • Events
  • Business
  • Energy
  • Technology
  • Contact Us
Sign in / Join

Login

Welcome! Login in to your account
Lost your password?

Lost Password

Back to login
  • Subscribe
  • Minerals
  • Projects
  • Machinery
  • Video’s
  • Advertise
  • Magazine
  • Directory

logo

Header Banner

Mining Focus Africa

  • Home
  • International News
  • Local News
  • Events
  • Business
  • Energy
  • Technology
  • Contact Us
  • SRK’s decade in DRC evolves to local ownership

  • BIA Group to supply Furukawa & RTDrill brands across Central and West Africa for Euroforgroup

  • Mozambique the next frontier in graphite production

  • BASE Resources passes important resource milestones in Kenya

  • Cable, components and critical space exploration

  • Africa’s edge in the green mineral economy

  • Keeping the faith in EA public participation processes during Covid-19

  • Ivanplats seeks $420m financing to develop South Africa’s Platreef mine

  • Transforming the Logistics Operations of the African Mining Industry

  • Mining Indaba insights: Mines push on as South Africa plays catch-up

Local News
Home›Local News›Trajectory of ‘progressive’ Charter changes will keep foreign investors wary of SA mining

Trajectory of ‘progressive’ Charter changes will keep foreign investors wary of SA mining

By Micheal van Wyk
November 11, 2020
60
0
Share:

Gwede Mantashe, mines and energy minister, South Africa

DESPITE the increasingly strident efforts of Minister Mantashe and his officials to have us believe “regulatory certainty” is ubiquitous, the mining regulation landscape in South Africa has become dramatically less certain since the introduction of Mining Charter III. Rather than creating investor certainty, he and his team have done precisely the opposite.

It is highly unlikely that foreign mining investors will return to South Africa in significant numbers, it is safe to say. One doesn’t have to look too far, or too hard, to see the reasons. South Africa is a mining jurisdiction in which vague, poorly drafted legislation and regulations are the norm. It is a place where politicians and officials believe they have full discretion on how to apply that legislation and regulations.

On top of that, the entire regulatory system rests on the dysfunctional SAMRAD (South African Mineral Resources Administration System) system which is broken. Acceptance and granting of prospecting right applications literally takes years, and when they are granted they often overlap other existing rights or are granted contrary to legislation.

In essence, the mining sector regulation in this country is now a confusing and secretive mess in which the only real way for prospective participants to achieve any momentum in terms of progressing their applications requires litigation or “connections” in the department.  A very unappealing prospect for foreign investors.

And while it may be hard to believe, those are not even the main reasons why investors will probably not return.

The main disincentive to foreign investment is rooted in the developing and gazetting new iterations of the Mining Charter. The minister determines what goes into the Charter, after consulting with various South African role players, absent, as far as I can tell any actual mining industry investors.

The original charter was a grand compromise that suited no-one, as is the nature of compromises. The government and ANC representatives went round the world to explain the necessity of the compromise to investors – and, I believe, promised that the 26% BEE ownership threshold would not change.

Minister Mantashe’s Mining Charter III broke that promise with an amendment asking for 30% BEE. This progressive trajectory is part of a tightening of the screws on all the other onerous requirements mining companies must bear from compelled procurement to social obligations. It is the setting of this trajectory that might well be the final nail in the South African mining sector’s coffin.

The bottom line is that there is now not even the slightest glimmer of certainty regarding Charter 4, 5 or 6. From a foreign investor’s point of view, this reveals the Charter to be less about creating a firm foundation for mining growth and social cohesion in South Africa, and more about the expropriation of growing portions of their already inherently risky future returns.

INVESTORS, NOT DONORS

The simple truth is that investors are investors, not donors. Given that a trajectory is set that can only result in lower, or even negative future returns to investors, the risks involved in investing in mining in this country far outweigh the potential long-term returns. And no foreign investor, in any sector, would find that a compelling proposition.

Minister Mantashe has tried to allay these fears by promising that he won’t exercise his right to amend the Charter at will, for at least five years following the finalisation of its latest draft.

Unfortunately, there is a history of broken promises which means that this guarantee won’t inspire confidence. Even if he is true to his word, the timeline means that a revised Charter is likely to make its appearance in 2023-2024 anyway, so there will be few mining companies and investors brave enough to make new long term investment decisions under those uncertain conditions.

Ultimately, the only real way to win back the interest of foreign investors is to provide them with a measure of certainty about what the future of the industry holds.

Unfortunately, the future of the industry has rarely been less certain. And South Africa doesn’t have, and has never had, a large enough savings base to be able to fund the mining industry on its own.

It depends on foreign investors for new investment. But if the so-called progressive Mining Charter process continues on its current course, foreign investment will keep drying up, until there will likely be very little left of an industry that was once the jewel in South Africa’s economic crown.

Paul Miller is a Director at AmaranthCX, a consultancy serving the African mining supply industry.

Previous Article

SGS to bring Glencore Technology’s Albion Process ...

Next Article

People near Broken Hill mine in Zambia ...

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0

Micheal van Wyk

Related articles More from author

  • Local News

    Zimbabwe struggles to save trapped miners as flood halts rescue

    November 30, 2020
    By Micheal van Wyk
  • Local News

    Virus-hit South African miners in battle for returning workers

    June 26, 2020
    By Micheal van Wyk
  • Local News

    SRK reflects on rock-related accidents in South Africa mining industry

    October 21, 2020
    By Micheal van Wyk
  • Local News

    BMO, Linklaters among the world’s top mining M&A advisers

    January 15, 2021
    By Micheal van Wyk
  • Local News

    Low female representation blights mining despite progress in some sectors

    February 16, 2021
    By Micheal van Wyk
  • Local News

    Mantashe monitors COVID-19 lockdown compliance at Mpumalanga coal mines

    April 1, 2020
    By Micheal van Wyk

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You may be interested in

  • Business

    Mining sector sees growth in second quarter

  • Energy

    Nersa allows Eskom to claw back R13.3bn in tariffs

  • Local News

    EXXARO: STRIVING TOWARDS EQUALITY FOR WOMEN IN MINING

Watch

  • EnergyVideo's

    South Africa reveals recovery plan for mining and energy sector

    Government has tabled a recovery plan to restore business confidence, stimulate investments, safeguard and create jobs in the mining and energy sector. “The Mining and Energy Recovery Plan intends to ...
  • Video's

    The draft petroleum Bill, skills development and how SA can benefit from Mozambique’s LNG project

    Adrian Strydom, acting CEO at South African Oil and Gas Association chats to African Oil Week on the draft Upstream Petroleum Resource Development Bill, Integrated Resource Plan, skill development for ...
  • Video's

    Steel production likely to stagnate or decline this year, says Roskill

    https://cisp.cachefly.net/assets/articles/attachments/82191_2020-05-05_roskill.mp4
  • Video's

    South Africa’s economy dire in comparison to rest of Africa

      Dr Azar Jammine, Director and Chief Economist at Econometrix, highlights the economic disparity between South Africa, West Africa and East Africa and how this could be an opportunity for ...
  • EventsVideo's

    Good Chemistry at Mining Indaba

    Under the umbrella of the new AECI Mining pillar, AECI Mining Explosives (AEL Intelligent Blasting) and AECI Mining Chemicals (Senmin), will offer solutions that focus on the customer and their ...

Timeline

  • February 24, 2021

    SRK’s decade in DRC evolves to local ownership

  • February 24, 2021

    BIA Group to supply Furukawa & RTDrill brands across Central and West Africa for Euroforgroup

  • February 23, 2021

    Mozambique the next frontier in graphite production

  • February 22, 2021

    BASE Resources passes important resource milestones in Kenya

  • February 19, 2021

    Cable, components and critical space exploration

Find us on Facebook

About Us

Mining Focus Africa provides valuable information on minerals’, events, exploration, energy and mining developments throughout Africa. It reports on the continent’s renaissance in mining and market opportunities associated with it.

Published 4 times a year, Mining Focus Africa is also available as a value-adding Digital online platform including weekly newsletter, online subscription and quarterly E-magazine downloads.

  • Recent

  • Popular

  • Comments

  • SRK’s decade in DRC evolves to local ownership

    By Micheal van Wyk
    February 24, 2021
  • BIA Group to supply Furukawa & RTDrill brands across Central and West Africa for Euroforgroup

    By Micheal van Wyk
    February 24, 2021
  • Mozambique the next frontier in graphite production

    By Micheal van Wyk
    February 23, 2021
  • BASE Resources passes important resource milestones in Kenya

    By Micheal van Wyk
    February 22, 2021
  • The way that minerals are mined affects conflict in eastern Congo

    By Micheal van Wyk
    July 30, 2019
  • Miners welcome stance against ‘blatant corruption’ in South Africa

    By Micheal van Wyk
    August 31, 2020
  • Wafi-Golpu a ‘game-changer’ for growing South Africa miner

    By Micheal van Wyk
    December 7, 2020
  • East Africa mining boom spells doom for environment

    By Micheal van Wyk
    December 4, 2020
  • JAQLEE CONSTRUCTION COMMENCING
    on
    February 1, 2021

    Mota-Engil picks up mining contract at Vedanta’s Gamsberg mine

    Good Day. Would like ...
  • www.xmc.pl
    on
    January 31, 2021

    Shock resignation of AngloGold Ashanti CEO after less than two years

    Spot on with this ...
  • Edison Forbes
    on
    January 6, 2021

    Contact Us

    I think this is ...
  • หนังโป๊
    on
    January 4, 2021

    Miners welcome stance against ‘blatant corruption’ in South Africa

    Excellent article. I certainly ...

Contact Us

Head Office
5 The Ferns, 364 Pretoria Avenue, Randburg, South Africa, 2194

Tell : +27 67 212 7565
Fax: 086 678 6956
www.lothbrokmedia.com

Accounts
Info@lothbrokmedia.com

Zambia
33 Malata Road, Madras,Lusaka, Zambia 3928Tell:+ 26 76 136 3654
Email Info
Info@miningfocusafrica.com

 

  • Contact
  • Adverts
© Copyright www.miningfocusafrica.com. All rights reserved.
Please wait...

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to be notified when our article is published? Enter your email address and name below to be the first to know.
SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTER NOW